An independent agency working with over thirty companies to ensure you get the proper coverage at the right price.
Contact our team

Our mission is to provide the

best-personalized customer experience

With over twenty-five years of experience in the construction industry, the Construction Group at Pilgrim Bay Insurance Agency offers unmatched expertise in insurance programs for contractors.

In today’s economy, savvy consumers are considering their options to save the most money, especially when it comes to insurance. With dozens of insurance companies and brokers available, are you prepared to spend your time comparing rates and coverage?

If you are a President, Executive Director, CFO, Human Resources, or Business Manager, we at Pilgrim Bay Insurance Agency bring a unique skill set to protect your institution, staff, directors, or trustees, and, of course, your students.

The Private Client Group at Pilgrim Bay Insurance Agency serves the unique insurance needs of High-Net-Worth individuals, Corporate Executives, and VIPs. 

Planning for your future and your family’s future should involve more than an app on your phone. There are often many factors that should be considered when purchasing life insurance. 


As a full-service, middle-market insurance brokerage, Pilgrim Bay Insurance Agency offers surety bonds for business owners in all types of industries.